CIA had Tamerlan Tsarnaev's name on terrorist database before Boston bombings
Story by Lucy Valencia, Assignment Desk Editor - email
(CBS) - The federal government added the name of the dead Boston Marathon bombing suspect to a terrorist database 18 months before the deadly explosions, a U.S. official told CBS News.
CBS News senior correspondent John Miller reports that the CIA made the request to add Tamerlan Tsarnaev's name to the terrorist database after the Russian government contacted the agency with concerns that he was associated with Chechen terrorists. About six months earlier, the FBI had separately investigated Tsarnaev, also at Russia's request, but the FBI found no ties to terrorism, the official told Miller.
Miller, a former assistant director of the FBI, said on "CBS This Morning" Thursday that the FBI did a full background investigation on Tsarnaev, running his name against databases and investigating whether he had come up in any cases or if any informants had mentioned him or if he was on any wiretaps. Then they questioned him and his parents.
"They write that up, send it back to the Russians and the important caveat, as they say, 'If you have more information that will allow us to dig deeper, please send it,'" said Miller. "The Russians never follow up with that."
The new disclosure that Tsarnaev was included within a huge, classified database of known and suspected terrorists before the attacks was expected to drive congressional inquiries in coming weeks about whether the Obama administration adequately investigated tips from Russia that Tsarnaev had posed a security threat. Shortly after the bombings, U.S. officials said the intelligence community had no information about threats to the marathon before the April 15 explosions.
Tsarnaev died Friday in a police shootout hours before his younger brother, Dzhokhar, was discovered hiding in a boat in a suburban back yard.
The terrorist database is called TIDE, the Terrorist Identities Datamart Environment. Analysts at the U.S. National Counterterrorism Center submit names and even partial names into TIDE. About a year ago, there were some 745,000 people listed in the database. Intelligence analysts scour TIDE, trying to establish connections and update files as new intelligence is uncovered.
For entries with a full name, date of birth and intelligence indicating a reasonable suspicion that a person is a terrorist or has terror ties, the person's name is sent to the database, which feeds into lists like the one that bans known or suspected terrorists from traveling on planes.
The official said the U.S. never found the type of derogatory information on Tsarnaev that would have elevated his profile among counterterrorism investigators and placed him on the terror watch list.
Five days after the U.S. determined who was allegedly behind the deadly Boston marathon terror attacks, Washington is piecing together what happened and whether there were any unconnected dots buried in U.S. government files that, if connected, could have prevented the bombings.
Lawmakers who were briefed by the FBI said they have more questions than answers about the investigation of Tsarnaev. U.S. officials were expected to brief the Senate on the investigation Thursday.
"The review is just beginning, but I haven't seen any red flags thus far," said Rep. Adam Schiff, a California Democrat who sits on the House Intelligence Committee and was briefed on the investigation Wednesday. House Judiciary Chairman Bob Goodlatte, R-Va., however, said lawmakers intend to pursue whether there was a breakdown in information-sharing.
Miller said the various agencies involved will assess how the investigation was performed in the months leading up to the bombing.
"This was not a big terrorism case when it was set," said Miller. "This was a fairly routine foreign-police cooperation issue."
"What the agencies will say is, 'We've got to go back over what we did with a fine-toothed comb because the question is not did we do it by the book. Sure we did. Could we have done it better if we had dug deeper or done it different?'" Miller said.
The official described to Miller what the government knew about Tsarnaev since he was first placed on the intelligence community's radar 18 months ago. The official spoke on condition of anonymity because they were not authorized to publicly discuss the ongoing investigation.
Russia's internal security service, the FSB, sent information to the FBI about Tamerlan Tsarnaev on March 4, 2011. The Russians told the FBI that Tsarnaev, an ethnically Chechen Russian immigrant living in the Boston area, may be associated with Chechen terrorists and had changed drastically since 2010. Because of the subsequent FBI inquiry, Tsarnaev's name was added to a Homeland Security Department database used by U.S. officials at the border to help screen people coming in and out of the U.S. That database is called the Treasury Enforcement Communications System, or TECS.
The FBI's Boston office opened a preliminary review of Tsarnaev and searched government databases for potentially terror-related communications. Investigators looked into whether Tsarnaev used online sites that promoted radical activity. They interviewed Tsarnaev and his family members but found nothing connecting him to terror activity. The FBI's review into Tsarnaev was closed in June 2011.
Then, in late September 2011, Russia separately contacted the CIA with nearly identical concerns about Tsarnaev. The Russians provided two possible birthdates for him and a variation of how his name might be spelled, as well as the spelling in the Russian-style Cyrillic alphabet.
The CIA determined that Tsarnaev should be included in TIDE, and the National Counterterrorism Center added it into the database. The spelling of Tsarnaev's name in TIDE was not the same as the spelling the FBI used in its investigation. The CIA also shared this information with other federal agencies in October.
In January 2012, Tsarnaev traveled to Russia and returned to the U.S. in July. Three days before he left for Russia, the TECS database generated an alert on Tsarnaev. That alert was shared with a Customs and Border Protection officer who is a member of the FBI's Boston joint terrorism task force. By that time, the FBI's investigation into Tsarnaev had been closed for nearly six months because the FBI uncovered no evidence that he was tied to terror groups.
On Jan. 21, 2012, the airline on which Tsarnaev was traveling misspelled his name when it submitted its list of passengers to the U.S. government for security screening. Airlines are required to provide the list of passengers on international flights so the U.S. can check their names through government databases, including the terrorist watch list. Because his name was misspelled, there was not another alert like there was three days earlier.
In July 2012, Tsarnaev returned to the U.S., and another alert was generated in TECS. This information was again shared with the Customs and Border Protection officer on the FBI's Boston joint terrorism task force. But because the FBI had closed its investigation into Tsarnaev a year earlier, there was no reason to be suspicious of his travels to Russia.
"Later on, these agencies will be judged," said Dutch Ruppersberger of Maryland, the top Democrat on the House Intelligence Committee. "But right now, it's way too soon to criticize or to start making political arguments or who failed or whatever."
Email Alert Sign Up
Sign up here to receive breaking news stories from KSWT.com and morning updates to your email inbox.
YUMA, AZ. (13 On Your Side) - It's been one day since Outback Steakhouse shut down unexpectedly leaving about 55 workers without a job. Employees found out after they showed up to work and found thisMore >>
It's been one day since Outback Steakhouse shut down unexpectedly leaving about 55 workers without a job. More >>
YUMA, AZ - Three college students arrested for robbing another college student faced a judge this afternoon. Tony Grimes, 20, Khambel Garland, 20, and 21-year old Nygee Lockhart are accused of robbingMore >>
YUMA, AZ - Three college students arrested for robbing another college student faced a judge this afternoon. Tony Grimes, 20, Khambel Garland, 20, and 21-year old Nygee Lockhart are accused of robbing someone in at Arizona Western College dorm room Monday evening.More >>
Troops based at the Kadena Air Base in Japan know how to party. On Saturday, six gay and straight service members applied some of their finest makeup and lip synced to "I Wanna Dance with Somebody" inMore >>
Gay and lesbian troops perform in drag on American military baseMore >>
HEBER, CA.- Sheriff's deputies arrest a suspect in connection to a shooting over the weekend. The Imperial County Sheriff's Office says 31 year old Gilbert Vasquez of El Centro shot at three people afterMore >>
The Imperial County Sheriff's Office says 31 year old Gilbert Vasquez of El Centro shot at three people after a verbal dispute over personal matters.
Calipatria--Nine inmates are in the hospital with moderate to serious injuries after a prison riot. It happened Saturday afternoon at the Calipatria State Prison. A prison spokesman said hundreds ofMore >>
Nine inmates are in the hospital with moderate to serious injuries after a prison riot. It happened Saturday afternoon at the Calipatria State Prison. More >>
Web Producer: Lucy Valencia, Assignment Desk Editor WASHINGTON (AP) -- Declaring "we are not a deadbeat nation," President Obama warned on Monday that Social Security checks and veterans' benefits willMore >>
Declaring "we are not a deadbeat nation," President Obama warned on Monday that Social Security checks and veterans' benefits will be delayed if congressional Republicans fail to increase the government's borrowing authority in a looming showdown over the nation's debt and spending.More >>
A man accused of murder in the slaying of four people, including an 18-month-old girl, at a farm in rural eastern Kansas will face the testimony of dozens of witnesses during a preliminary hearing slated to begin...More >>
A woman whose decomposing body was found under a pile of clothing next to the body of her boyfriend at a Kansas farm had been bound at the wrists and was partially clothed, crime scene specialists testified Tuesday.More >>
ZOFT Gum has begun a thirty one day period of creative engagement with the ZOFT brand, enlisting contributors from across social media to playfully recreate the company logo. Port St. Lucie, FL, USA – March...More >>
ZOFT Gum has begun a thirty one day period of creative engagement with the ZOFT brand, enlisting contributors from across social media to playfully recreate the company logo. Port St. Lucie, FL, USA – March 11, 2014...More >>