Does JCPenney's Back-to-School Ad Really Promote Bullying?
Story by 13 On Your Side Newsroom
(Yahoo! News) - A JCPenney back-to-school ad that implies kids will be friendless unless they wear the right clothing is promoting bullying, charged a flurry of critics on social media this week.
"Your ad about cool kids wearing JCPenney clothes, showing a child sitting alone at lunch is despicable," fired off one Facebook user.
Another added, "How clueless are you? What a horrible bully-promoting commercial."
Twitter users have called it "tone deaf" and "more self-immolation" for the company.
The ad, posted online by the retailer in late July and aired as part of a TV campaign earlier this summer, includes a shot of a kid in a school cafeteria, surrounded by friends.
When the mom in the voice-over talks about the importance of buying her child cool school clothes, she notes, "I've been told this stuff can make or break your entire year." At that moment, all the kids except for one disappear from the room.
That message was enough to prompt the national antibullying organization Stand for the Silent to kick off a campaign against the ad.
My wife and I lost our 11-year-old son to suicide due to being bullied, and yes ma'am we do oppose this ad," founder Kirk Smalley told Yahoo! Shine in an email.
"We feel it does promote excluding kids that don't wear the ‘right' clothes.
This is totally against what we have spent our entire savings on and the last three years of our lives traveling to speak at schools and teach these kids.
We've spoken at 715 schools and to over 740,000 kids and taught them, ‘You are somebody,' and that you are not what you wear, what religion you believe, what color your skin, etc."
But JCPenney said that it did not mean to spread a negative message and has responded to critics with an official statement, which it shared with Yahoo! Shine.
"Our intent was not to trivialize or promote bullying," it read. "At JCPenney, we're committed to carrying a broad range of styles that let kids express their individuality and make a positive first impression. Our marketing is meant to inspire kids to create and reveal their look as they head back to school this season.
The ad is part of a handful of back to school TV ads we are airing this season.
It aired earlier this summer as scheduled but is not currently part of our TV campaign."
A spokesperson added that JC Penney has an anti-bullying track record, recently launching initiatives to support organizations including Crisis Text Line (a youth-crisis intervention program),DoSomething.org and Stomp Out Bullying.
Plenty of Facebook users appear to be on the retailer's side, slamming critics for making an issue out of nothing.
"People you are looking way too into the commercial," wrote one fan on Facebook. "You guys are the people who pick everything apart and take everything to extremes. You also need to not [take] everything to heart and so seriously."
Another added, "This world is way to p/c these days! Its not about bullying, get over it you cry babies!!!!" On YouTube, a commenter chimed in, "What's the big fuss about? I see nothing wrong with this crappy commercial. Calm down people."
Still, Bully-Free West Virginia asked JCPenney via Facebook to remove its ad, sticking by its charge, "This is promoting bullying and stereotyping."
Others pointed out that many families simply don't have a choice when it comes to spending money on new clothing, and that the ad's message would only ostracize those kids.
"Completely disgusting that you would help promote the stupid childish statuses of clothing brands!!!!" wrote an angryFacebook user. "Do you know how many children HAVE to wear secondhand or Walmart clothing?!?!?!"
A fellow commenter added, "My parents couldn't buy me new clothes every school year especially not from JCP, which is a store I like for its variety, but this was just hurtful."
"You're telling kids that the only way they'll be liked is if they wear the right clothes and look a certain way," another commenter posted. "You're telling them that everyone at school will be judging them based on what they're wearing.
In what world is this okay?"
The bottom line, antibullying expert, speaker and counselor Joel Haber told Yahoo! Shine: "People are expecting more responsibility nowadays.
They are expecting people to treat each other with more respect. And companies can do that even if they are going for a certain market share."
As for JCPenney, he noted, "It sounds like they crossed the line."
Email Alert Sign Up
Sign up here to receive breaking news stories from KSWT.com and morning updates to your email inbox.
BLYTHE, Calif. — U.S. Border Patrol agents from the Blythe Station found multiple weapons during a traffic stop. Agents pulled over a 2013 Ford Taurus near Blythe, Calif., and got consent to search theMore >>
U.S. Border Patrol agents from the Blythe Station found multiple weapons during a traffic stop.More >>
YUMA, Ariz. (13 On Your Side) – A man is facing first degree murder charges in connection to a San Luis stabbing that left one man dead and another wounded. Salvador Sigala, accused of stabbing a 25-year-oldMore >>
A man is facing first degree murder charges in connection to a San Luis stabbing that left one man dead and another wounded.More >>
On December 4, 2013, at 02:30 pm, Elizabeth Romero was abducted from Kennewick, Washington. Elizabeth Romero a 14 year old, Hispanic, female, 5 feet 3 inches tall, weighing 130 pounds, brown hair, andMore >>
The suspect is Eduardo Flores-Rosalas, a 19 year old, Hispanic, male, 5 feet 9 inches tall, weighing 200 pounds, with black hair, brown eyes, unknown clothing.
Former Cocopah police chief James Spurgeon will not face charges for shooting and killing 25-year-old josh collins. Police say Spurgeon acted in self defense. The deadly shooting happened on SaturdayMore >>
Police say Spurgeon acted in self defense. The deadly shooting happened on Saturday October 26th. More >>
PHOENIX (AP) - Phoenix police say a 3-year-old boy being pushed in a stroller in a crosswalk was fatally injured when he was struck by a pickup truck at a midtown intersection. Sgt. Steve Martos saysMore >>
Phoenix police say a 3-year-old boy being pushed in a stroller in a crosswalk was fatally injured when he was struck by a pickup truck at a midtown intersection.More >>
YUMA, Ariz. (13 On Your Side) - More than 30 teams showed up to Yuma Catholic's annual Rachel Determan Rib Cook-Off, ready to grill and show off their best ribs. This year, "the Chicharones" took homeMore >>
More than 30 teams showed up to Yuma Catholic's annual Rachel Determan Rib Cook-Off, ready to grill and show off their best ribs.More >>
TEMECULA, Calif. (AP) - A Riverside County father and teen daughter have each been placed on four years' probation after pleading guilty to charges in a vigilante attack on a man the girl had accused ofMore >>
The girl claimed Cruz raped her in November 2012 after she passed out after drinking alcohol at his home.More >>
YUMA, Ariz. (13 On Your Side) – In a massive drug sting aimed at one of the most powerful Mexican drug cartels, the Imperial Valley Narcotics Task force arrested ten drug smugglers trafficking meth andMore >>
In a massive drug sting aimed at one of the most powerful Mexican drug cartels, the Imperial Valley Narcotics Task force arrested ten drug smugglers trafficking meth and cocaine across the border from Mexicali.More >>